American Civil Liberties Union v. Mineta

OPINION

PAUL L. FRIEDMAN, District Judge.

This matter originally came before the Court on plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction. That motion is now moot and has been replaced by a request for a permanent injunction in connection with plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment. The defendants also have filed a motion for summary judgment. Upon consideration of plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, defendants’ opposition, defendants’ motion for summary judgment, plaintiffs’ opposition, defendants’ reply and the joint stipulation of material facts agreed to by the parties, the Court…