Quigley v. Bennett

In this case we consider whether evidence of the value of a royalty interest in minerals can be considered in determining compensation for geologic services when the services were not rendered pursuant to a written agreement. We determine that it cannot.

In early 1997, Michael Quigley decided to sell his interest in oil and gas leases known as the Samano leases. Robert Bennett, a geologist, agreed to help Quigley by analyzing the leases and assisting with a sales presentation to Louis Dreyfus Natural Gas. Bennett did not expect to be paid; he agreed to do the presentation as a favor to a sick…