Knutson v. State Ex Rel. Seberger

Dissenting Opinion

Bobbitt, J.

I dissent from the majority opinion for the following reasons:

Courts in Indiana do not have the jurisdiction or the power to tell a lower tribunal in whose favor or in what manner a judgment shall be rendered. State ex rel. Beatty v. Nichols, Sp. J., etc. (1954), 233 Ind. 432, 120 N. E. 2d 407; Schuble v. Youngblood (1947), 225 Ind. 169, 173, 73 N. E. 2d 478; State ex rel. Burton v. Gelb (1947), 225 Ind. 330, 334, 75 N. E. 2d 151; State ex rel. Ripa v. Lake Superior Court (1942), 220 Ind. 436, 438, 43 N. E. 2d 871; The State ex rel. Reynolds v. The Board of…