Owings v. Pool Well Service

ALMA WILSON,

Justice, dissenting:

The result reached by the majority fulfills the prediction expressed in my dissent in Parks v. Norman Municipal Hospital, 684 P.2d 548 (Okla.1984). The inevitable consequence of the Parks decision is the one reached by the majority in its opinion, that is, if the issue is one of evidence, the decision of the three judge panel will be rubber stamped by the appellate court if the panel uses the words “against the clear weight of the evidence” in the panel’s Order on Appeal. Even if a cursory examination of the record reveals that the clear weight of the evidence…