Legal Opinion · Dissent

Collins v. City of Bryant

Court of Appeals of Arkansas

Decided June 19, 2013No. CV-12-1053Published

1DissentBrandon J. Harrison, Judge

I disagree with the majority’s use of Rule 60 to reinstate the attorney’s-fee award. We should affirm the circuit court’s decision to vacate the award. Doing so would respect a prior precedent from this court, fundamental notions of fairness, and no case from our supreme court requires otherwise.

In November 2010, the circuit court held a trial on the plaintiffs’ complaint. The main issue tried was whether a city employee was authorized to contract with the Collinses on the location of a storm-drainage easement on the Collinses’ property. The jury found for the Collinses and returned a $70,000…

2Cases cited7 opinions

  1. Ward v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2003
  2. Pettus v. McDonaldSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2001
  3. Craig v. CarrigoSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2003
  4. Entertainer, Inc. v. DuffySupreme Court of Arkansas · 2012
  5. Seidenstricker Farms v. DOSS FAMILY TRUSTSupreme Court of Arkansas · 2008

2 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API