Smith v. Williams
Court of Appeals of Tennessee
1DissentNearn, Judge
I do not agree that it is harmful reversible error to afford litigants a jury without their consent. In view of our harmless error statutes (T.C.A. §§ 27-116, 117), it is incongruous to me to say that a party has been injured to such extent that a new trial is required because twelve men, instead of one, decided that party’s dispute. In fact, I do not believe that appellant Williams, believes that it was reversible or harmful error. His first Assignment of Error is *508“The Trial Court erred in failing to sign the Agreed Order waiving the Jury.” The entire argument found in the brief on this…
2Cases cited1 opinion
- Caudill v. Mrs. Grissom's Salads, Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court · 1976