Fuller v. Sovereign Camp, W. O. W.

(dissenting) : I am convinced that the defendant’s motion for a directed verdict in this case should have been granted, and therefore I dissent from the affirmance of the judgment indicated in the opinion of Mr. Justice Stabler, for the reasons which follow:

The undisputed facts are that on March 30, 1922, the defendant issued to William PI. Fuller, through one of its local camps, at Fair Play, S. C., a certificate of membership in the fraternal association, carrying insurance upon his life in the sum of $1,000, the plaintiff, Mamie Fuller, his wife, being named as beneficiary. Pie paid the…