Alexander v. Butterfield

PICARD, District Judge.

Motion for summary judgment by defendant against plaintiff’s action to set aside an order of deportation, and for in-junctive relief.

The questions in this case are very few:(1) When defendant notified plaintiff of a hearing on his deportation, charging that plaintiff became a member of the Communist Party in this country after his entry, was it fatal for defendant not to grant the bill of particulars requested by plaintiff before said hearing?(2) At the time of the hearing, April 9, 1954, when defendant was quizzing two of its own witnesses, was it fatal *77for defendant…