Legal Opinion · Dissent

City of Philadelphia v. Civil Service Commission

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided June 20, 2005Published

1DissentJustice Saylor

I agree with the City of Philadelphia’s central position distinguishing an eviden-tiary precept crafted by the Legislature relative to a specific administrative compensation scheme from interpretive principles that are more readily amenable to more generic application. As I would limit the application of the 52-week exception of Section 422 of the Workers’ Compensation Act to the setting in which it has been prescribed, I also agree with the City that the rule embodied in Walker v. UCBR, 27 Pa.Cmwlth. 522, 367 A.2d 366 (1976), pertained to the administrative proceedings in which Officer…

2Cases cited7 opinions

  1. Walker v. Unemployment Compensation Board of ReviewCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1976
  2. Rox Coal Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeal BoardSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 2002
  3. Benson v. Workmen's Compensation Appeal BoardCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1996
  4. Calcara v. Workers' Compensation Appeal BoardCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1998
  5. Koppers Co. v. Workmen's Compensation Appeal BoardCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1988

2 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API