Murphy v. Hasenflue

Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Connor, J.), entered July 17, 1992 in Ulster County, upon a verdict rendered in favor of plaintiff.

Following a motor vehicle accident in which plaintiff’s car was struck from behind by defendant’s vehicle, plaintiff commenced this action. Defendant conceded liability and the matter was tried before a jury on the issues of serious injury and damages. At the conclusion of proof as to serious injury, plaintiff moved for judgment, Supreme Court directed a verdict in plaintiff’s favor and the jury awarded damages. Defendant appeals and we reverse.

It is…