Mayfield Co. v. First Nat. Bank of Terrell

Not being able to agree with my associates in the disposition of this appeal, I hereby file the following dissenting opinion:

The only question involved is; Was the' trial court in error in instructing a verdict,' for the appellees? The evidence upon the trial, as shown by the majority opinion, was brief and uncontroverted. Plaintiff in garnishment has no better right against the garnishee than his judgment debtor, and, if nothing is owing to the latter, the former is entitled to nothing. Hall v. Nunn Electric Co. (Tex. Civ. App.) 183 S. W. 13 (error refused); Smith v. Houston Exchange Bank…