Abbott v. National Bank of Commerce of Tulsa

I am unable to concur in the legal reasoning by which a majority of my associates arrive at the conclusion announced in this case.

It is undisputed in this case that notice of acceptance of the instrument herein involved (whether it be a “mere offer of guaranty” oí-an absolute guarantee) was not given by- the National Bank of Commerce of Tulsa (guarantee) to Charles T. Abbott (the guarantor). The whole question in this case is whether such notice of acceptance was necessary. That, in turn, depends upon whether there was a “mere offer of guaranty” or an “absolute guarantee,” notice being…