Tilles v. Department of Labor of the State

These four proceedings are under article 78 of the Civi Practice Act (in the nature of mandamus proceedings). In each the petit oners applied originally for peremptory relief, claiming that they were ent'tled to permanent civil service status superior to certain other persons. Peremptory relief was denied by the *576Special Term and the Appellate Division. (See 257 App. Div. 308.) The opinion on affirmance remitting the matter to this court contained the following direction: “ The circumstances surrounding the appointment of each petitioner and each intervenor must be determined upon evidence,…