W.Va. Employers' Mutual Insurance d/b/a Brickstreet Insurance Company & Michael D. Riley v. The Bunch Company

LOUGHRY, Justice:

Petitioners West Virginia Employers’ Mutual Insurance Company doing business as BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Company (“BrickStreet”) and Michael D. Riley, 1 the West Virginia Insurance Commissioner (“Commissioner”) appeal from the October 31, 2011, order of the Circuit Court of Kana-wha County, which reversed and vacated the Commissioner’s July 9, 2010, administrative order upholding previously approved rates. At issue below was an assertion by the respondent, the Bunch Company (“Bunch”), that the premium it paid to BrickStreet wrongly included a charge for an agent com…