Haas v. O'Connell

Judgment unanimously reversed upon the law and new trial granted, with thirty dollars costs to appellant to abide the event.

The court should not have directed a verdict as there were questions of fact in the case and defendant asked to go to the jury. In truth, the court did not determine any question of fact, saying there was none. A tenant who holds over after a term of a year or more may be treated at the option of the landlord either as holding for another year, or as a trespasser. (Kennedy v. City of New York, 196 N. Y. 19, 23; United M. Realty & Imp. Co. v. Roth, 193 id. 570, 576.) But…