Murrain v. Wilson Line, Inc.

The order for examination is too indefinite in that it requires an officer “ having knowledge ” to attend and requires “ such relevant ” books and records to be produced. *180The order should specify the officer to be examined and the documents required.

The requirement for a bill of particulars of the defense of contributory negligence is also improper in this case. There are no allegations that plaintiffs are without knowledge of the facts surrounding the accident, or that the information with reference to the accident is wholly in the possession of the defendant. It is only under such…