Campbell v. City of Helena

HONORABLE W. H. MEIGS', District Judge,

sitting in place of MR. JUSTICE GALEN, disqualified, dissenting:

The view I take of this case compels me to dissent. Called to sit herein in the stead of Mr. Justice Galen, one of the ablest jurists this state has produced, who himself dissents upon occasion, I would fain be in harmony with my brethren on the law of the ease. To be so in this instance, however, would cause me to feel that I have failed in the conscientious discharge of the imperative duty resting upon me, not to re main silent — the easy way — but to set forth the reasons for the faith…