Carman v. City of New York

The issues in this case are similar to those discussed in Golding v. City of New York, 140 N. Y. Supp. 1020, decided herewith. In view of the opinion handed down in the Golding Case, it is unnecessary to traverse the ground again in this case. The same defenses are raised by the defendant herein, and further comments would be Unnecessary, were it not for the fact that the learned corporation counsel makes an additional point, which was omitted in the Golding Case.

Certain rules and schedules of the municipal civil service commission were introduced in evidence, showing that at the time of the…