WPW Acquisition Co. v. City of Troy

*290O’Connell, P.J.

In these five cases consolidated on appeal, plaintiffs1 appeal as of right from various trial court orders from the Oakland and Wayne Circuit Courts. In each case, we are asked to decide whether Const 1963, art 9, § 3 provides that plaintiffs are entitled to taxable values of real property that, as percentages of true cash value, equal the average ratio of taxable value to true cash value of all other property in the taxing district.2 Because we agree with the trial courts’ conclusion in each case that Const 1963, art 9, § 3, as amended by Proposal A, imposes no such…