Miracle Boot Puller Co. v. Plastray Corp.

We cannot agree with our brother Bronson’s disposition of the troublesome question of jurisdiction involved herein.

Our brother begins his analysis by conceding that:

"While this [Court’s previous] holding assumes that a state court has jurisdiction over such a conversion claim, the Court never so determined; the specific issue of jurisdiction was never raised nor addressed.3 (Emphasis added.)

Yet, a few paragraphs later he states:

"Thus, as we held that plaintiff’s claim arose under state law, state courts had jurisdiction over the claim.” (Emphasis added.)

The prior decision never held that…