Erie Insurance Group v. Baum

Reginald J. Routson, Judge.

These consolidated cases come on for consideration by the court as a result of cross-motions for summary judgment filed by the parties. For purposes of this decision, Lightning Rod Mutual Insurance Company and Steven C. Baum shall be referred to in the singular as the “plaintiff,” and Erie Insurance Group and David Schilling shall be referred to as the “defendant.”

Upon consideration of the motions, the memoranda of law, and the evidentiary material submitted by the parties, the court finds as follows.

*4 STATEMENT OF FACTS

On December 25, 1989, plaintiff Steven C. Baum,…