Legal Opinion · Concurrence

University of Utah Hospital v. Clerk of Minidoka County

Idaho Supreme Court

Decided April 27, 1988No. 16151Published

1Concurrence

BISTLINE, Justice,

specially concurring.

Only because I am not at all persuaded by the final paragraph of the opinion au*666thored by Justice Bakes does it become necessary to write. In all other respects I agree with his opinion. For reasons appearing, infra, we very easily, and better, could have left our 1987 opinion in place.

I

For certain I do not in the least agree that our first opinion of April 23, 1987, should be withdrawn. On a number of sessions I have pointed out that the practice of withdrawing opinions is not salutary in effect. To withdraw an opinion necessarily carries with it the…

2Cases cited11 opinions

  1. State v. HoisingtonIdaho Supreme Court · 1983
  2. Carpenter v. Twin Falls CountyIdaho Supreme Court · 1984
  3. State v. OwsleyIdaho Supreme Court · 1983
  4. Workman Family Partnership v. City of Twin FallsIdaho Supreme Court · 1982
  5. Summers v. DooleyIdaho Supreme Court · 1971

6 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API