People v. Tripoli

Titone, J.,

concurs and votes to affirm the judgment, with the following memorandum: The core issue is whether a warrantless seizure of simulated stolen property from a camper trespassed upon the defendant’s constitutional rights (US Const, 4th Arndt; NY Const, art I, § 12). Because the sui generis nature of a camper has spawned arguably conflicting decisions on the questions (cf. People v Carney, 34 Cal 3d 597 [majority opn, and dissenting opn Richardson, J.], cert granted_US_; United States v Wiga, 662 F2d 1325; United States v Williams, 630 F2d 1322; State v Lepley,_Minn_, 343 NW2d 41), I…