Gruner v. McNamara

This proceeding relates to the same civil service examination for police sergeant which was previously reviewed in Matter of Blumenthal v. Morton (273 App. Div. 497, affd. 298 N. Y. 563).

The final order required the Civil Service Commission to select a single best answer to such questions as it deemed capable of such an answer.

Question No. 60, which was retained by the commission, reads as follows:

“ 60. Shortly after a robbery a patrolman stopped an automobile in which were four men and a driver. Underneath the rear seat he found a loaded revolver. One of the occupants h¡ad a license to carry…