Butterfly Realty v. James Romanella & Sons, Inc.

Supreme Court No. 2013-15-Appeal. (WC 10-406) Dissent begins on page 19 Butterfly Realty et al. : v. : James Romanella & Sons, Inc. : Present: Suttell, C.J., Goldberg, Flaherty, Robinson, and Indeglia, JJ. OPINION Justice Indeglia, for the Court. In this appeal, we revisit an ongoing dispute between two commercial landowners over the existence of a prescriptive easement used by delivery trucks to access a loading dock. The plaintiffs, Butterfly Realty and Dairyland, Inc. (plaintiffs), appeal from a Superior Court judgment denying their claim for a prescriptive easement on the property of the…