Commonwealth, Governor's Office of Administration v. Pennsylvanians for Union Reform, Inc.

DISSENTING OPINION BY

Judge COHN JUBELIRER.

I respectfully dissent. Rather than affirm the Office of Open Records’ (OOR) Final Determination, I believe this matter should be remanded to the OOR to examine, as requested by the Governor’s Office of Administration (OA), the evidence submitted by numerous Commonwealth agencies in a case involving the same Requester, Pennsylvanians for Union Reform v. State Employees Retirement System (PFUR v. SERS), OOR Dkt. AP 2013-1830.

The Majority holds, for the first time, that county of residence is not a component of home address and, therefore, OA may only…