State v. Naranjo

(specially concurring).

I agree with the result reached, and with respect to the issues delineated in the majority opinion, I wish to state my additional reasons for reversal.

A. The indictment was insufficient upon which to charge perjury.

In its entirety, Count IV read as follows:

[The grand jury of Santa Fe county, State of New Mexico, accuses the defendant of the following crime[s]:

COUNT IV

PERJURY, in that on or about the 4th day of December, 1976, the Defendant, EMILIO NARANJO, did make a false statement under oath or affirmation, material to the issue or matter involved in the course of a…