Aetna Casualty and Surety Company v. Joseph A. Tryniecki

JOHN R. BROWN, Circuit Judge.

This relatively simple damage suit arises from an uncomplicated set of facts and raises but two questions for our consideration. The first is the sufficiency of the evidence on liability and damages. The second question is whether the trial judge committed prejudicial error in admitting into evidence over the objection of the Appellant the deposition of a chiropractor who examined and treated Tryniecki subsequent to the accident. The case was tried before a jury. On the conclusion of the evidence the Judge overruled motions for directed verdicts made by both…