Legal Opinion · Dissent

Territory v. Sing High

Hawaii Supreme Court

Decided November 17, 1909Published

Reserved Question erom Circuit Court, First Circuit.

1Dissent

DISSENTING OPINION OP

WILDER, J.

There is a clear distinction between occupations which may be regarded as harmful or dangerous in themselves, such as that of selling intoxicating liquors, and those which, like keeping a lodging house or doing a laundry business, are necessary to the welfare or convenience of the community, and which are harmful or dangerous, if at all, only because in the particular way in which they may be conducted. In the former no person has an absolute right to engage; in the latter all persons have an equal right to engage. The former may be regulated or restricted to…

2Cases cited7 opinions

  1. City of Richmond v. DudleyIndiana Supreme Court · 1891
  2. Brown v. BrownHawaii Supreme Court · 1897
  3. In re Tai KeeHawaii Supreme Court · 1899
  4. The King v. Tong LeeHawaii Supreme Court · 1880
  5. In re Tai KeeHawaii Supreme Court · 1897

2 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API