Goodwin v. The Fishing Vessel

GILLIAM, District Judge.

It appears from the uncontradicted evidence that at about 4:00 o’clock a. m., on September 5, 1955, the “Sweet Pea” was rammed and sunk by a wooden hull fishing vessel, the identity of which is at serious issue. Libellants accuse the “Jackie B” and have offered evidence tending to substantiate the accusation, while respondent, the “Jackie B”, and her owner, vigorously deny guilt and have of*293fered evidence tending to support the denial. This is the only substantial issue of fact presented and there is no controversy with respect to the applicable legal principles. The…