Missouri Consolidated Health Care Plan v. Community Health Plan

I. Did the Plaintiff Make a Case on the Counts for Misrepresentation and Breach of Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing?

The central issue before the court is whether the defendant, a state entity seeking bids on health insurance for state workers, is liable to the plaintiff, Community, because it materially misrepresented facts about the contract Community was making a bid upon. The evidence favorable to the submissions showed that during the negotiations, the highest ranking person of MCHCP deliberately told the bidder that no historical figures were available to determine whether the…