Legal Opinion · Dissent

Jenna Gordius v. Randall G. Kelley

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided May 26, 2016No. Docket Han-15-100Published

1DissentAlexander, J.

[¶ 21] I respectfully dissent.

[¶ 22] This appeal addresses a sad scenario that recurs hundreds or thousands of times a year in Maine — a child’s parent with primary residence of a child has a long-term relationship with a friend, fian-cée, or spouse who is not the child’s biological parent. The friend, fiancée, or spouse develops a positive, parent-like relationship with the child. The child’s parent and the friend, fiancée, or spouse then separate, and the child is saddened, or, as the trial court found here, “hurt” by the loss of contact with the now ex-friend, fiancée, or spouse.

[¶ 23] The…

2Cases cited6 opinions

  1. Troxel v. GranvilleSupreme Court of the United States · 2000
  2. Rideout v. RiendeauSupreme Judicial Court of Maine · 2000
  3. Matthew W. Pitts v. Amanda M. MooreSupreme Judicial Court of Maine · 2014
  4. Wandishin v. WandishinSupreme Judicial Court of Maine · 2009
  5. Davis v. AndersonSupreme Judicial Court of Maine · 2008

1 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API