Creighton v. Hershfield
Montana Supreme Court
Appeal from Third District, Lewis The facts are stated in the opinion, which has been delivered in this case on the first appeal. 1 Mon. 689. The judgment was rendered by Wade, J. [The arguments of counsel are the same as those which are reported in the other hearings of this ease, and are omitted.]
1Opinion of the CourtSeevis, J.
This action was originally commenced in the court below, June 21, 1870, and the appellants recovered judgment at a subsequent term. A new trial was granted afterward, at the December term, 1871, and the appellants appealed to' this court. At the August term, 1872, this court affirmed the judgment of the court below in granting a new trial, and the cause was remanded. 1 Mon. 639. Upon the second trial in the .court below judgment was rendered for the respondents, and this appeal was taken.
However much I might be inclined to differ from the opinion of this court, which has been referred to (1…
2Cases cited1 opinion
- Lick v. DiazCalifornia Supreme Court · 1872
3Cited by3 opinions
- Carlson v. Northern Pacific Railway Co.Montana Supreme Court · 1929
- State v. ZimmermanMontana Supreme Court · 1977
- Maddox v. TeagueMontana Supreme Court · 1896