Legal Opinion
Commonwealth v. Fake
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Decided August 13, 1979No. Appeal, No. 999 C.D. 1978PublishedCited by 5 opinions
1Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
Judge Craig,
This is an appeal by the Department of General Services of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (eon*48demnor) from an order of the Conrt of Common Pleas of Lebanon County denying condemnor’s motion for a new trial. We affirm the lower court.
In 1976, the condemnor condemned two tracts of land owned by Leroy Fake and Florence Ditzler (condemnees), consisting of an eight-acre and a sixty-one-acre tract, separated by a public road. The condemnees also owned, by separate deed, a mountain tract of approximately 112 acres, located directly behind the 61-aere tract. At the time of…
2Cases cited6 opinions
- Stoner v. Metropolitan Edison Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1970
- Elgart v. PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1959
- Brown v. Redevelopment AuthorityCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1978
- Nobel v. West Penn Power Co.Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1978
- H. C. Frick Coke Co. v. PainterSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1901
1 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.
3Cited by5 opinions
- Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Co.Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · 1991
- City of San Diego v. NeumannCalifornia Supreme Court · 1993
- In re Condemnation by Penn Township, York County, of Right-Of-Way & Easements Over, Across & Through Tracts of Land Located in Penn Township, York CountyCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · 1997
- City of San Diego v. NeumannCalifornia Supreme Court · 1993
- James E. Hughes and Linda L. Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Co., Consol-Land Development Co., Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Dorothy Loughman v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt, and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Paul H. Kent and Mabel Kent v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. James C. McIntyre and Glenna McIntyre v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Larry Levine, Dan Levine, Morris Levine, Edward Levine, Individuals, and Morris Levine Enterprises, Inc., a Corporation, and Levine Iron and Metal, Inc., a Corporation v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Dorothy Loughman v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, Consolidated Coal Co., Consol-Land Development Company, and the Monongahela Railway Company, Dorothy Loughman v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, and Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Dorothy Loughman v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, Mike Wilson, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke David Boggs, an Individual, the Upshur Agency, Inc., William Reese, an Individual, Mike Wilson, an Individual, John W. Yesenosky, Jr. And Linda M. Yesenosky v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, and the Monongahela Railway Company, John W. Yesenosky, Jr. And Linda M. Yesenosky v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh, and Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Paul H. Kent and Mabel Kent v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Paul H. Kent and Mabel Kent v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, James C. McIntyre and Glenna McIntyre v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, James C. McIntyre and Glenna McIntyre v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Larry Levine, Dan Levine, Morris Levine, Edward Levine, Morris Levine Enterprises, Levine Iron & Metal v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Larry Levine, Dan Levine, Morris Levine, Edward Levine, Morris Levine Enterprises, Levine Iron & Metal v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, James Hughes and Linda Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, James Hughes and Linda Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Thomas J. Allen v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Thomas J. Allen v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Dorothy Loughman v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, John W. Yesenosky, Jr. And Linda M. Yesenosky v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. John W. Yesenosky, Jr. And Linda M. Yesenosky v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, John W. Yesenosky, Jr. And Linda M. Yesenosky v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Paul H. Kent and Mabel Kent v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, Paul H. Kent and Mabel Kent v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., James C. McIntyre and Glenna McIntyre v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, James C. McIntyre and Glenna McIntyre v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Larry Levine, Dan Levine, Morris Levine, Edward Levine, Morris Levine Enterprises, Levine Iron & Metal v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, Larry Levine, Dan Levine, Morris Levine, Edward Levine, Morris Levine Enterprises, Levine Iron & Metal v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., James Hughes and Linda Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, William Reese, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, James Hughes and Linda Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Mark E. Headlee and Charlotte B. Headlee v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Mark E. Headlee and Charlotte B. Headlee v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Mark E. Headlee and Charlotte B. Headlee v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft Mbh, Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke, Mark E. Headlee and Charlotte B. Headlee v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, Mark E. Headlee and Charlotte B. Headlee v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Thomas J. Allen, Esquire, Personal Representative of the Estate of John T. Throckmorton v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke. Thomas J. Allen, Esquire, Personal Representative of the Estate of John T. Throckmorton v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Ewing Pollock, and Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, Thomas J. Allen, Esquire, Personal Representative of the Estate of John T. Throckmorton v. Consol-Pennsylvania Coal Company, a Corporation, Rhein Braun U.S., a Corporation, Monongahela Railway Company, a Corporation, Mike Wilson, an Individual, William Reese, an Individual, James Leach, an Individual, David Boggs, an Individual, Ewing Pollock, an Individual, and the Law Firm of Pollock, Pollock and Thomas, the Upshur Agency, Inc., Consolidated Coal Company, Consol-Land Development Company, Rheinbraun Verkaufsgesellschaft, Mblt and Maria Therese Verkaufsgesellschaft, Maria Theresia Bergbaugesellschaft, Mbh & Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke Mike Wilson, William Reese, David Boggs, the Upshur Agency, Inc.Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · 1991