Judge v. American Motors Corp.

I concur in the court’s decision affirming the summary judgment on the false advertising claim. I respectfully dissent from the remand to the district court to decide whether Florida law or Michigan law should apply, for the reasons set forth in the Order of the district court, a portion of which is attached hereto as an Appendix.

This accident took place in Mexico in a rented vehicle manufactured by a Mexican corporation subject to Mexican design specifications. The rental agreement was negotiated and executed in Mexico by the plaintiff Florida resident with a Mexican company. The car was…