National Labor Relations Board v. Robbins Tire & Rubber Co.

HUTCHESON, Circuit Judge.

This is another in that long list of enforcement proceedings, in which, galled by the appearance of unfairness1 made by a record in which the Board acts as both accuser and judge,2 the employer rebels against the findings of Examiner and Board as arrived at to accomplish the board’s “pre-determined purpose of punishing this respondent.”

While from a human standpoint, such an approach is understandable, it is calculated on the record before us to generate more heat than light, and not to be very helpful in the discharge of our part in the administro-judicial process the…