Ponderosa Homesite Lot Owners v. Garfield Bay Resort, Inc.

BURDICK, Justice.

This case comes to the Court once again for a determination of who owns the “lake access” area found in the Ponderosa Home Sites Subdivision (PHS) in Bonner County, Idaho. After remand, the district court determined Rita S. Walker Thayer (Thayer) owned the “lake access,” subject to a perpetual easement granted to the PHS lot owners. Clifford and Steve Dove (Dove) appeal this decision. 1

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

This is the second time this Court has heard an appeal in this matter. In the first appeal, this Court described the “lake access” and its history.

On…