American Broadcasting Co. v. United States

Judge LEIBELL’S masterly analysis of the case shows that the only point of doubt or concern is as to whether “consideration” is given in return for a chance at substantial and valuable prizes or financial awards. Though earnestly argued by the several plaintiffs, the other contentions — some rising to the constitutional level — are unconvincing and I agree with the court in overruling them. But on the one issue which thus proves controlling, I do not feel that my brothers have reached a result which is consistent with law, or, indeed, with reason, and I accordingly dissent.

Before I turn to…