Satellite Broadcasting and Communications Association v. Federal Communications Commission United States of America, Association of America's Public Television Stations Public Broadcasting Service Corporation for Public Broadcasting National Association of Broadcasters Consumer Federation of America Office of Communication, United Church of Christ, Incorporated, Intervenors. Echostar Satellite Corporation v. Federal Communications Commission United States of America, Association of America's Public Television Stations Public Broadcasting Service Corporation for Public Broadcasting National Association of Broadcasters Consumer Federation of America Office of Communication, United Church of Christ, Incorporated, Intervenors. National Association of Broadcasters, Paxson Communications Corporation, Intervenor v. Federal Communications Commission United States of America, Association of America's Public Television Stations Public Broadcasting Service Corporation for Public Broadcasting Consumer Federation of America Office of Communication, United Church of Christ, Incorporated, Intervenors. Satellite Broadcasting and Communications Association Echostar Communications Corporation Dish, Limited, D/B/A Dish Network Directv Enterprises, Incorporated Directv Operations, Incorporated Directv, Incorporated, and National Association of Broadcasters the Association of Local Television Stations, Incorporated the Univision Network Limited Partnership and Univision Television Stations, Incorporated, Intervenors/plaintiffs v. Federal Communications Commission William E. Kennard, Chairman Susan Ness, Commissioner, in Her Official Capacity Harold Furchtgottroth Michael K. Powell, Commissioner, in His Official Capacity Gloria Tristani, Commissioner, in Her Official Capacity United States Copyright Office Library of Congress James H. Billington, Librarian of Congress Mary Peters, Register of Copyrights, in Her Official Capacity United States of America, Association of America's Public Television Stations Public Broadcasting Service Corporation for Public Broadcasting, Intervenors Pegasus Communications Corporation Channel Master Llc, Parties in Interest. National Cable Satellite Corporation (C-Span) Space Systems/loral, Incorporated Paxson Communications Corporation Consumer Federation of America Office of Communication, United Church of Christ, Incorporated National Alliance for Media Arts & Culture Association of Independent Video and Filmmakers Virginia Citizens Consumer Council Conexant Systems, Incorporated Broadcom Corporation, Movants

Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit