Grubb v. Smith

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

JUSTICE HUGHES

This case has had a long procedural history, including two attempted removals to federal court, two trips to the Court of Appeals, and now a second visit to this Court, but it began life as, and remains, a fairly straightforward personal injury suit arising from a February 1, 2007 trip-and-fall at the Speedway SuperAmeriea filling-station in Manchester, Kentucky. In the ensuing 2010 bench trial, the Clay Circuit Court found for Plaintiffs, Teresa Grubb and her husband Randy Grubb, and against Speedway SuperAmeriea LLC (Speedway), the store’s owner, and…