Nagle v. Jin Suey

DIETRICH, Circuit Judge.

IAppellee sought admission as the foreign-born son of one Jin Fung For, who, it is conceded, is by birth a citizen of and resides in the United States. Holding the evidence to be insufficient to establish the alleged paternity, the administrative officers denied the application, whereupon the applicant brought tbis proceeding, in habeas corjrns, and from an order below granting his prayer the Commissioner of Immigration. appeals.

But for certain discrepancies in the testimony to which we shall later refer, unquestionably the applicant made a very strong case in the…