Saginaw Bay Transportation Co. v. Portage Entry Quarries Co.

WINCH, J

The proposition that the verdicts in these three eases, all *534of which depend upon the same facts, were not supported by sufficient evidence, was argued to us with so much earnestness that we have reviewed the evidence with more than usual care. "While there is an irreconcilable conflict between the evidence given by the plaintiff’s witnesses and that given by the defendant’s witnesses, still we think that the evidence of one of the witnesses for the plaintiff, Alexander F. MeDougall, has an air . of verisimilitude, and that if he was believed by the jury, as they seem to have believed…