Beckwith v. Township of Van Buren

This case has formerly been before this Court, and will be found reported in 52 Mich. 383.

The members of the Court who sat in the case then are all agreed that the case as now brought here does not essentially differ in any of its material features from the first record in this Court. They consider that the opinion in 52 Mich, disposes of the case upon the merits against the plaintiff.

- After a careful examination of the present record, not haying been a member of the Court when the case was first presented here, I am also satisfied that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover upon the…