Allegheny Valley School v. Pennsylvania Unemployment Compensation Board of Review

I am compelled to dissent. Ultimately, the legal issue to be decided in this appeal is what analytical framework shall be used to determine the propriety of unemployment compensa*367tion benefits in matters where an employee who is demoted because of performance shortcomings leaves his employment. Today, the majority adopts an incomplete and inadequate analytical framework which I believe is contrary to both the language of the Unemployment Compensation Law (Law)1 and this court’s prior decisions. Unfortunately, the majority rejects the more comprehensive and fair analytical framework recently…