People v. Valentine

OPINION OF THE COURT

William M. Simon, J.

These motions are consolidated for one opinion based upon the fact that the issues in both cases are the same.

*932The defendants are both charged in informations with two counts arising out of a graduation party held at their residence in Greene County, New York in June of 2010. The charges stem from an accusation that various minors were in attendance at the graduation party and that alcoholic beverages were supplied to them by allowing them access to various coolers that contained beer. The first charge is the misdemeanor of unlawfully dealing with a…