Sutton v. Premier Insurance

Troy, Paul E., J.

The Plaintiff Andrew P. Sutton (“Sutton”), filed this action against the defendants, The Premier Insurance Company of Massachusetts (“Premier”), and the Board of Appeal on Motor Vehicle Liability Policies and Bonds (“Board”), seeking judicial review of the Board’s decision upholding a surcharge imposed by Premier upon Sutton. Sutton filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. The court held a *48hearing on the motion at which Sutton appeared through counsel and the Board waived its appearance. For the reasons discussed below, Sutton’s motion is ALLOWED and the Board’s decision…