Legal Opinion · Dissent
Jamal Wright v. the State of Louisiana on Behalf of Jamie Alleyn, M.D., Ashley Van Wormer, M.D., Monique Sutherland, M.D., Megan Bina, D.O. and Ashely M Hirsch, M.D.
Louisiana Court of Appeal
Decided August 5, 2020No. 2019-C-0499Published
1Dissent
JAMAL WRIGHT, ET AL * NO. 2019-C-0499 VERSUS * COURT OF APPEAL THE STATE OF LOUISIANA * FOURTH CIRCUIT ON BEHALF OF JAMIE ALLEYN, M.D., ASHLEY VAN * STATE OF LOUISIANA WORMER, M.D., MONIQUE SUTHERLAND, M.D., MEGAN * BINA, D.O. AND ASHELY M HIRSCH, M.D. * ******* TFL LOVE, J., DISSENTS AND ASSIGNS REASONS I respectfully dissent from the majority, as this matter is governed by jurisprudence that has yet to be countermanded. Rather than relying upon Velasquez and its progeny, I find that this case is governed by the principle reiterated in Gaffney v. Giles, 14-0384, p. 23 (La. App. 4 Cir.…
2Cases cited5 opinions
- Carter v. HaygoodSupreme Court of Louisiana · 2005
- Ermert v. Hartford Ins. Co.Supreme Court of Louisiana · 1990
- Sampay v. Morton Salt Co.Supreme Court of Louisiana · 1981
- Gettys v. WongLouisiana Court of Appeal · 2014
- Gaffney v. GilesLouisiana Court of Appeal · 2015