H & R Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

I dissent.

The trial court held that:

The Plaintiff’s Lien is invalid and thus its Complaint insofar as it seeks a foreclosure must be denied. However, it will stand to the extent that the Complaint demands Judgment against Defendants, Clair F. Wieseler, AJH, Inc., and Alex Group.

*154If it is valid for judgment purposes, why isn’t it valid for mechanic’s lien purposes?

In Ringgenberg v. Wilmsmeyer, 253 N.W.2d 197 (S.D.1977), this court held that: “ ‘Where the work is contracted for as an entirety for a specific amount, ... all the information is given that is needed or can reasonably be required.’ ”…