Vandegrift v. United States

*171DISSENTING OPINION

Barber, Judge:

I can not see my way clear to concur in the views of my associates in this case. Beads have been provided for eo nomine in practically every tariff act, including and since the act of 1832. In none of these has Congress limited or restricted such eo nomine provisions to beads that were ornamental or suitable for •decorative purposes. No such restrictive language is found in paragraph 1403 and in my opinion it is wiser to leave such a limitation to the legislative body, especially as no judicial tribunal or executive department, so far as has been ascertained,…