Legal Opinion · Concurrence

Columbia Falls Elementary School District No. 6 v. State

Montana Supreme Court

Decided March 22, 2005No. 04-390Published

1ConcurrenceJustice Nelson

¶42 I concur in our Opinion, although I perceive a need for further remarks regarding our power to enforce non-self-executing constitutional rights.

¶43 First, in General Agric. Corp. v. Moore (1975), 166 Mont. 510, 534 P.2d 859, our view of what sort of provision is and is not self-executing was softened somewhat from the definition we adopted in State ex rel. Stafford v. Fox-Great Falls Theatre Corp. (1942), 114 Mont. 52, 132 P.2d 689. In General Agrie., we stated:

“A provision is self-executing when it can be given effect without the aid of legislation and there is nothing to indicate that…

2Cases cited9 opinions

  1. State ex rel. Whiteside v. First Judicial District CourtMontana Supreme Court · 1900
  2. Gray v. BryantSupreme Court of Florida · 1960
  3. Kloss v. Edward D. Jones & Co.Montana Supreme Court · 2002
  4. Morgan v. Board of Sup'rsArizona Supreme Court · 1948
  5. State Ex Rel. Stafford v. Fox-Great Falls Theatre Corp.Montana Supreme Court · 1942

4 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API